Oberlin Blogs

Vulnerability and Culpability

January 28, 2009

Alice Ollstein ’10

I haven't done any traveling since that daytrip to cross the border last week, but I have been doing a lot of thinking. In class, on the bus, talking with my fiercely proud Mexican host-mom and reading the news...without the constant social swirl of Oberlin I've had a lot of time to mull over some of the difficult issues we've been studying. I'm sure my ideas and the presentation of my arguments will improve as the semester goes on, but here are a couple things that have been bumping around in my head.

For one, as a journalist, I'm always looking at how the media covers immigration and border issues, both in reporting and in op-eds, and I'm tired of how, for the most part, the drug war is being portrayed as "Mexico's problem." I've seen countless headlines where the message is either "Will their violence spill over and hurt us?" or "Aren't we so nice to offer to help Mexico with its problem?" Some examples from today alone are:

"US prepares to back Mexican drug war"
"Mexico's deadly drug war is growing threat to US"
"Does What Happens in Mexico, Stay in Mexico?"
"Mexican collapse? Drug wars worry some Americans"

One particularly offensive columnist wrote today that "sub-human Mexican animals' barbaric behavior could eventually endanger the lives and well being of Americans on the U.S. side of the border."

Very few are asking who is buying the drugs, who is receiving the drugs on our side of the border, and who is supplying the weapons. The answer to all three is, unsurprisingly, Americans. While it might be easier to pretend that the whole mess is the problem of stereotypically "corrupt" and "lawless" Mexico, we need to examine our own roles in the situation. It also pisses me off that my college peers go on and on about local food and organic cotton clothes but don't give a crap about where their drugs come from and how they arrived (I include coffee and cigarettes as "drugs" here, as they are often produced in ways harmful to the earth and workers).

Anyway, the drug war, whether it's our "problem" or not, is having a definite effect on migration. Though several experts predicted that thousands of undocumented workers would leave the U.S. and return home because of our slumping economy and lack of jobs, those already here are afraid to return, and thousands more have attempted to cross the border to flee the violence. The question is, do we offer these people sanctuary as refugees, or do we build our walls higher and criminalize them to the point where who they are is "illegal"? Most people talk about "keeping them out," but never think about what kind of environment they are simultaneously keeping them in--one not only of extreme poverty but of violence and fear.

I'm not yet at the point where I can argue for any certain policy, but I wanted to throw a few ideas out there and see what you readers think. I hope to hear from you soon.

Responses to this Entry

Which papers are those headlines from?

Posted by: Anonymous on January 30, 2009 2:13 AM

In order, those newspapers are:
La Voz Nueva
Corpus Christi Caller-Times
Business Week
and our friends the Associated Press

Posted by: Alice on January 30, 2009 7:46 PM

Alice, great work pulling in references to the way the media slant treatment of "the drug wars." Where on earth does that one columnist live ("sub-human Mexican animals' barbaric behavior" - that one)?

How do the Mexican media deal with the same events? (I know that's too big a question, but I know you're thinking about it.)

Keep up the great blogs.

Posted by: Bert Woodruff on February 1, 2009 11:21 AM

The thing about the Mexican media is that reporters writing about the drug war are constantly in danger of being killed by the cartel leaders. Reporters Without Borders has a good report about this on their website if you're interested. Also, search for a recent L.A. Times article about a Mexican reporter who fled to the U.S. for his life and asked for asylum, but was held in jail for like 8 months before they processed his case. So much for the people who say, "If they would just come here legally..."

Posted by: Alice on February 1, 2009 12:48 PM

Hi Alice!
You might remember me from your Cultural History of Tango class last semester...
I came across your blog because I was searching for the OSCA/coop website, and then I started reading about your Border Studies experience.
I COMPLETELY agree with you about the drug comment. I've often wondered, with all the activism at Oberlin and supposed awareness, why people here don't take issue with using drugs (well, maybe some are "locally-grown" drugs haha) when drug usage in the US is what's fueling the war in Mexico and killing billions of people.....I'm glad you wrote that here.
I hope you have an amazing time at border studies...I've been kind of obsessed with that program and I hope I can go on it someday, but I dunno if that will ever happen, so for now I'm just going to read the rest of your posts online here so I can live vicariously (i hope i spelled that right..) through your experiences if you don't mind!
Have fun!
Anne :)

Posted by: Anne on February 7, 2009 11:32 PM

Hi Anne! Glad you're interested in Border Studies. It's an incredible program. Thanks for reading the blog, too. If there's any questions you have or anything you think I should write about, let me know.

Posted by: Alice on February 8, 2009 1:33 AM

Just found another one: "Mexico drug violence pushes across border" The Denver Post

Posted by: Alice on February 10, 2009 10:53 PM

Leave a Comment

Similar Blog Entries

Winter Term in Southeast Asia

March 8, 2023

Ilana McNamara

I spent my Winter Term in Indonesia and the Philippines learning about the musical cultures of both countries, meeting incredible people, and maybe even learning something about myself along the way.
Ilana looking off to the side with a blurry nature background