Syllabus for Review of Research in Music Education: MUED 502
Dr. Jody L. Kerchner, Instructor
Class Meeting : MW 11-11:50am
Phone: x8267, R115
Semester Hours: 2
E-mail: jody.kerchner@oberlin.edu
Office Hours: Check office door for weekly hours and/or call for an appointment
Course Description: Introduction to techniques of research in music education; critiques of research studies both as an overview of the field and in relation to a specific area chosen by the student. Consent: Consent of instructor required. Enrollment limit: 6. Open only to Music Education majors in the MME or MMT programs.
Course Objectives: This class was designed in order for you:
- To develop an understanding of the vital role that research plays in music education
- To develop skills that will enable you to decipher published research in the field of music education
- To develop critical thinking skills that are necessary to evaluate research design, methodology, and conclusions
- To develop clear and concise written and verbal critiques of reviewed music education research
- To develop an inquisitive nature about research issues in the field of music education
Course Outcomes:
By the conclusion of the semester you will be able to:
- Describe the most common modes of research employed in music education and the methodology utilized in each mode
- Demonstrate a working knowledge of standard library reference tools used to conduct research
- Read, abstract, and critique a wide range of research studies published as theses, dissertations, and professional research journal articles
- Identify several music education research issues about which you are curious
- Develop an annotated bibliography about one of your identified research wonderments
- Develop and submit a formal written research project proposal based on your bibliography and your selected wonderment. Both MME and MMT students are required to submit a formal project proposal. MME students approved proposals will serve as the foundation for their research project to be conducted in the Spring semester.
- Complete and report on a survey study
- Complete and report on an observation studya thick description
Requirements:
1. All written assignments must be typewritten, double-spaced, and well-written (correct grammar, spelling, syntax), using APA format.
2. Due dates are fixed. Written assignments are due at the time of the class meeting on the date they are due.
3. Class presentations will not be accepted after the due date.
4. Punctual attendance and active participation are required. "Attendance" refers to regular classes, any field trips, and special presentations by Guests. "Participation" means a willingness to answer/ask questions both in and out of class and cooperative-learning sessions, a demonstration of preparedness, and an active role in discussion.
Absence does not excuse you from meeting the due date for assignments and presentations. If you are unable to attend class, you are expected to notify the instructor. Two unexcused absences will lower your final grade by one letter grade. Absences thereafter will continue to lower your final grade by one letter grade.
| Grading: |
|
|
Attendance and participation |
(see #4 above) |
| Journal article critiques |
15% |
| Journal reviews |
10% |
| Annotated bibliography |
20% |
| Survey Project |
10% |
| Thick description/Log |
15% |
| Final research project proposal |
30% |
Materials:
**COURSE TEXT: Rainbow, E. & Froehlich, H. (1987). Research in music education. New York: Schirmer. (ON RESERVE IN CONSERVATORY LIBRARY)
Notebook
Tape recorder/videotape (optional)
References:
Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, Spring 1998, #136, pp. 56-89.
Delzell, J. (Spring 1999). Effects of melodic pattern difficulty and performance experience on ability to play by ear. Journal of Research in Music Education, 471), pp. 53-64.
Flowers, P. & Murphy, J. (Fall-Winter 2001). Talking about music: Interviews with older adults about their music education, preferences, activities, and reflections. Update, 20(1).
Hebert, D. & Shehan Campbell, P. (2000). Rock music in American schools: Positions and practices since the 1960s. International Journal of Music Education, 36, p. 14-22.
Kerchner, J. (Fall 2000/2001). Childrens verbal, visual, and kinesthetic responses: Insight into their music listening experience. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 146, pp. 31-50.
Morrrison, S. (Spring 2000). Effect of melodic context, turning behaviors, and experience on the intonation accuracy of wind players. Journal of Research in Music Education, 48(1), pp. 39-52.
MUED 502: Review of Research in Music Education Tentative Course Schedule
| Date |
Class Content |
Assignment Due |
| M2/3 |
Class introduction: What is research?
|
Journal review assignment distributed |
W2/5
|
Modes of research; style manuals; technical aspects of writing source citations |
Read: R&F Chpts. 1, 2 |
| M2/10 |
Wonderments: which types of data are appealing? Bibliography assignment distributed
|
Bring list of wonderments to class; Read: R&F Chapt. 3 |
| W2/12 |
Writing a critique of music education research |
Read CRME (Spring 1998) dissertation reviews/critiques |
| M2/17 |
Qualitative research paradigm: observation
and thick descriptions
|
Journal review #1 (IJME) |
| W2/19 |
Conservatory Library: Library research tools |
Read: Bresler & Stake in Handbook of Research in Music Teaching and Learning; Research question submitted |
| M2/24 |
Creating and interpreting surveys,
interviews, and questionnaires
|
Critique #1: Kerchner |
| W2/26 |
Creating and interpreting surveys,
interviews, and questionnaires
|
Journal review #2 (JRME) Revised research question submitted |
| M3/3 |
Qualitative research paradigm: coding and
interpreting data (verbal protocol analysis
and content analysis)
|
Read: R&F Chpt. 9; |
| W3/5 |
Writing a research proposal: assignment distribution
|
Read: R&F Chapt. 4;
Annotated Bibliography due |
| M3/10 |
Quantitative paradigm: experimental and
quasi-experimental design
|
Read: R&F Chpt. 8 |
| W3/12 |
Quantitative paradigm: mean, median,
mode, standard deviation, bell curve
|
Outline of research proposal due (skeleton); Read: R&F Chpt. 10 |
| M3/17 |
Quantitative paradigm: null hypothesis,
probability, correlation, ANOVA, t-tests, significance |
|
| W3/19 |
Quantitative paradigm: reliability, threats
to internal validity
|
Critique due: Morrison |
| 3/23-30 |
SPRING BREAK |
ENJ OY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| M3/31 |
Thick description presentation |
Thick description report |
| W4/2 |
Working with statistics program |
|
| M4/7 |
Semantic differential and Q-sort |
|
| W4/9 |
No class: MENC meeting in Nashville, TN |
|
| M4/14 |
Dissertation presentation |
Verbal presentation (summary and critique) of dissertation; handout of presentation |
| W4/16 |
Outline of research project proposal
individual meetings TBA
|
Detailed paragraph outline of research proposal |
| M4/21 |
Guest speaker: Dissertation presentation |
|
| W4/23 |
Historical research |
Read Standifer article and
R&F Chpt. 6 |
| M4/28 |
Survey reports |
Survey report and printed supporting data displays |
| W4/30 |
Philosophical inquiry |
R&F Chpt. 7; Read Green article |
| M5/5 |
Discuss/refine research project proposal in
class; graduate exit exam question distribution
|
Research project proposal draft submission |
| T5/13 |
Noon Reading Period |
FINAL PROPOSAL DUE |
|