Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Fourteen to Seven Weeks: Oberlin’s Condensed CI Course




  •     Alison Ricker
  •     Science Librarian


2
Our Approach 15 Years ago
  • Sporadic library instruction for specific course-related assignment
  • Initiated by faculty
  • No coordination within the major or between librarian/faculty
  • Faculty desired a more structured approach, consolidating haphazard BI sessions into one coherent course
3
CHEM 396 at Oberlin
  • Developed in 1993 as a 14-week, full-semester course
  • Initial planning: weekly meetings of faculty and librarian during late summer to develop syllabus, exercises, readings, assignments
  • Goal:  research and honors students develop IL strategies before advanced research
  • Course content evolved rapidly as   resources changed
4
Reducing the Course to 7 Weeks
  • Revamped in 2003 on Pass/No Pass basis, still 1 credit
  • Strongly recommended for all majors
  • Prerequisites: Organic Chemistry + one other core chemistry course
  • Both instructors present at all class sessions
  • Meets one evening per week for 1.5 hours
5
What We Gave Up
  • Detailed instruction on general and interdisciplinary databases
  • Separate session devoted to evaluating information (popular vs. scholarly, bias in research, discussion of peer-review process, determining validity of Web sites, etc.)
  • General introduction to Web search engines
  • Separate session on chemistry data found on the Web
6
Components of Course
  • Students research a topic in teams of two
  • Investigate a compound on their own
  • General investigation methods stressed as well as resource-specific skills
  • Database comparison and evaluation
  • Topics for investigation selected from list developed by all chemistry faculty
  • Chemical compound “from cradle to grave”
7
Course Outline
  • From essential print and general resources to highly specialized
  • Class sessions: review, presentation, demonstration, hands-on practice
  • Weekly problem sets reinforce class session
  • Penultimate assignment: oral presentation with handouts
8

Collaboration Benefits
  • Complimentary knowledge and skills enriches course content
  • Shared responsibility for teaching and evaluation reduces relative work load
  • Check and balance relationship helps refine assignments
  • Better support during hands-on practice in classroom
9
Collaboration Pitfalls
  • Two procrastinators = stress, poor planning!
  • Misunderstandings based on incomplete or faulty communication
  • Different assumptions regarding course goals, appropriate assignments, work load, etc.
  • Inherent difficulties between individuals of different status/rank


10
Evaluating the Students
  • Written work
    • Weekly problem sets reviewed by both instructors
    • Problem sets provide more detailed exercises and practice than can be accommodated in class
    • Emphasize process rather than the right answer



11
Evaluating the Students, cont.
  • Oral presentation and handout
    • Both members of the team participate fully in the presentation
    • Most student create PowerPoint presentations, but it is not required
    • All class members and instructors hear all presentations
    • Students could benefit from more practice and advice beforehand



12
Student Responses
  • Want to focus on current research rather than pre-selected topics
  • Homework each week takes too long
  • Can’t always login to remote databases to complete homework
  • “I knew some of this already, but also learned a lot”
  • “I’m a better researcher because of this course”
13
What We Observed of Students
  • Quick recognition of the value and necessity of peer-reviewed literature
  • Appreciation for comprehensiveness of SciFinder Scholar (and ease of use)
  • Little patience for anything perceived as busy work
  • Reluctance to vary search strategy in different databases, or to expand list of relevant keywords and subject headings


14
Contact Information
    • Alison Ricker
    • Science Librarian
    • Oberlin College Science Center
    • 119 Woodland Avenue
    • Oberlin OH 44074-1097

    • Phone:  440.775.5146
    • Email:  alison.ricker@oberlin.edu